10 Reasons Your Thumb Clicks When You Knit, And Why Resting It Makes It Worse

Margaret Whitmore

Summary: Nobody told you the joint at the base of your thumb is sliding, not failing. That's not your fault. Here's what a hand therapist who works with knitters and crocheters does about it.

1. It clicks when you knit and goes quiet when you stop. Age doesn't do that.

Arthritis from age doesn't come and go with the stitching. A loose joint does. The joint is the CMC, at the base of your thumb, and years of gripping the needle have worn the ligament that holds it steady. Every stitch shifts it past itself. That's why it flares twenty minutes in, and why you say one more row anyway.

2. Resting it doesn't tighten it back up

Your body swells the tissue to protect the joint, and the swelling stiffens it, so the next stitch hurts more. So you stop. Two weeks in the drawer and it settles, but nothing else does. It isn't a hobby. It's your sanity, your therapy, the thing that gets you through the day. Then you pick them up and within the hour it's back, usually worse.

3. Every other brace holds the wrong thing

Compression gloves squeeze the swelling. Rigid splints lock the whole thumb. Neither one holds the joint that's actually moving. The Knitter's Hand Stabiliser uses a contoured CMC pad, shaped to sit over that one joint and hold it steady while your thumb still bends. Not a squeeze. Not a cast. A stop.

4. A locked thumb can't work a stitch

Every splint that holds the joint also takes your hand out of the game. This one leaves all four fingers free, so you grip and tension the yarn exactly as you always have. Knitters, crocheters, quilters, hand-sewers: the grip stays yours.

5. Built by a hand therapist, not a marketing team

Designed with Dr Simmons, a Hand therapist with 7 years treating knitters and crocheters. These were the patients she watched get handed a golfer's brace and sent home. She shaped the pad around how a knitter's thumb actually moves.

6. The advice you keep getting doesn't hold the joint

"Rest it." "Switch to Continental." "Find another hobby." Rest doesn't hold the joint, and plenty of lifelong Continental knitters click anyway. A cortisone shot buys a few months, then less, then the talk turns to surgery.

SUMMER SALE
FREE GIFTS WITH YOUR ORDER

Buy One, Get the Second 50% Off

Free shipping on orders over $50

DEAL ENDING IN: 00:00:00
Sell-Out Risk: VERY HIGH
FREE SHIPPING

60-Day Money-Back Guarantee

[Most people order one for each hand, second pair half price.]

7. Your thumb doesn't take days off, so this doesn't either

Soft, lightweight, no velcro to snag your yarn. Comfortable enough to stay on for a whole afternoon, not twenty minutes at a stretch.

8. The simpler it is, the more you'll use it

Slide it on. Cast on. Take it off at night. No referral, no waiting list, no learning to knit again at seventy.

9. Over 30,000 people stopped putting their wool away

Less clicking. Longer sittings. Finishing the blanket they'd told the grandchildren wouldn't be finished. Not miracles. Just what happens when the joint stops sliding.

10. If the click doesn't stop, you lose nothing

60-day money-back guarantee. Wear it through a full afternoon of knitting. Still clicking? Send it back, return postage covered, no questions.

SUMMER SALE
FREE GIFTS WITH YOUR ORDER

Buy One, Get the Second 50% Off

Free shipping on orders over $50

DEAL ENDING IN: 00:00:00
Sell-Out Risk: VERY HIGH
FREE SHIPPING

60-Day Money-Back Guarantee

Most relevant
17 comments
Profile picture
Olivia Wilson
Can anybody vouch for these?
3
Like Reply 1d
Reply profile picture
Emily Lewis
Yes, these braces are the only thing that helps. They're not a miracle, but definitely provide extra support. Before the pain at the base of my thumb had got so bad that I had to stop after twenty minutes. With these braces, I'm back to knitting most evenings again.
Reply image
Like Reply 1d
Profile picture
Annie Jones
Crocheting is my life line. Yes, arthritic pain. I am not stupid enough to go near a doctor. Knitting for 61 years and crocheting for 33 years.
3
Like Reply 3d
Profile picture
Zoe Cummings
Mine just arrived today, thank you! I'm knitting again. I had to stop for a while but the suppopry works beautifully which is why I have ordered more. (I don't want to wear one out and have to shelve my needles again) Thank you for developing this.
Comment image
Like Reply 3d
Profile picture
Dawn Taylor
Thanks for putting this on, I am having problems with recovering from a trigger finger op , after previous successful ops on other fingers in the past. You inspired me to be proactive and have an appointment with a hand remedial clinic so hopefully this will ease my problem.
3
Like Reply 1w
Profile picture
Sheila Simmons
I stopped knitting due to arthritis in my index fingers. I’ve now started felting, it’s just as satisfying.
1
Like Reply 1w
Profile picture
Shirley Baker
I am 71 and in the last 2 years had both thumb joints replaced and was told by my physio that the best exercise was knitting which has helped me get the movement back in my hands.
8
Like Reply 2w
Profile picture
Margaret Summers
Has anyone actually tried this? My thumbs have been getting worse for years and my doctor just keeps offering me cortisone shots. I'm 64 and frankly terrified of surgery.
3
Like Reply 2w
Reply profile picture
Susan White
Margaret I bought one in February. Wear this every time I sit down to knit and the deep ache has definitely reduced.
1
Reply image
Like Reply 2w
Profile picture
Kathie Jackson
Switching from English style throwing to European style scooping helped me over a period of thumb problems, as did adopting shorter (the bit you hold) circular needles help my wrists.
2
Like Reply 1w
Profile picture
Pauline Smith
Ok but is it actually different from the $30 ones on Amazon?? I've bought about five of those over the years and every single one broke at the seam within a week. Usually at night
4
Like Reply 3w
Reply profile picture
Janet Bailey
Janet I had the exact same thought. The Amazon ones either fall apart or they're so bulky you can't actually knit while wearing them. This one is slim enough that you can still hold the needles properly. Two months in and the structure hasn't budged.
6
Like Reply 2w
Profile picture
Thelma Davies
Embroiders, Crocheters, have the same, problem with Arthritis. Painful, but, what else is there, when you love it so much, plus if you’re in a group , it’s extra special. We have to keep our fingers and, brain active. I have been hand sewing for over seventy years, and, don’t intend to stop now. Just adapt.
7
Like Reply 3w
Profile picture
Jennifer Bale
It doesn't say whether it's for the left or right hand. I need it for my right hand.
Like Reply 3w
Reply profile picture
Julie McGrann
Jennifer, it says each order contains a pair, I wanted it for my left and found the info in the product details section.
Like Reply 3w
Profile picture
Avery Jackson
Does anyone know how long the shipping takes? Want to buy some for the girls at knit n natter
1
Like Reply 4w
Reply profile picture
Linda Wright
Hey Avery, mine arrived after about a week
Reply image
Like Reply 4w